Neutralgeneralactive

Rental Demand Strong, but Supply Overhang Delays Recovery

With home prices and mortgage rates making ownership unattainable for many, the rental market is seeing sustained demand growth. REITs focused on multifamily housing and build-to-rent communities may benefit. Evaluate supply dynamics and rent growth trends.

Conviction:
6/10
By:Tate Steele
Updated February 16, 2026

Rates Research

(1 entry)
Neutral0-5 Year
Confidence: 7/10|Conviction: 5/10
The housing affordability crisis thesis presents a **mixed-to-positive case for rental market growth over 5 years**, supported by structural demand tailwinds but tempered by significant near-term headwinds that create a bifurcated market dynamic. The fundamental driver—the widening gap between ownership and rental costs—remains robust and structural, with only roughly 12.7% of renters able to afford to buy a median-priced home in their market and the cost of homeownership nearly three times higher than average apartment rent as of late 2025. This affordability gap continues to force renter household formation and extend lease tenure, creating a durable demand base. However, the multifamily sector is experiencing a severe cyclical correction that will persist into mid-2026, with multifamily advertised asking rents marking the weakest performance since the global financial crisis with zero year-over-year growth and multifamily vacancy rates finishing 2025 near 8.5% as new supply outpaced demand. The structural affordability advantage tilts toward rental housing—particularly workforce and Class B multifamily—but market selection and geographic positioning become critical factors: supply-constrained Northeast and Midwest markets outperform significantly while oversupplied Sun Belt metros face years of rent compression. For retail investors with a 5-year horizon, the thesis benefits from declining supply (completions down 50%+ from peak), demographic tailwinds from younger cohorts unable to save for down payments, and eventual rent reacceleration beginning 2H 2026, but near-term rent volatility and REIT sentiment extremes pose near-term valuation and NAV risks. Build-to-rent single-family remains challenged amid policy headwinds and pricing pressures, while traditional multifamily REITs are positioned to benefit only after supply absorption completes.

Key Data Points

indicator: Mortgage Rate (30-year fixed)
value: 6.09%
source: Freddie Mac PMMS (as of Feb 12, 2026)
implication: Rates down 78 bp YoY but still elevated by historical standards; modest relief improving affordability but insufficient to unlock mass homebuyer migration; expected to trade in 5.75%-6.30% range through 2026. Structural affordability headwind remains.
indicator: Median Home Price (US)
value: $423,261
source: Redfin (January 2026)
implication: Up 1.1% YoY, with forecasts of 2.1%-4.0% growth in 2026. Limited inventory and price stickiness prevent meaningful affordability improvement despite lower rates; home prices have risen ~55% since Q1 2020 per Fed data, pricing out middle-income buyers.
indicator: Housing Affordability Payment-to-Income
value: <30% of household income (projected Q1 2026)
source: FNBO/Industry Consensus (January 2026)
implication: First time since 2022 that median mortgage payment drops below 30% affordability threshold; modest improvement from 3.5% wage growth outpacing 2.6% inflation. However, absolute home prices remain historically unaffordable for middle-income cohorts.
indicator: Multifamily Vacancy Rate
value: 7.3%-8.5%
source: Apartment List / CoStar (Q4 2025 / January 2026)
implication: Record-high vacancy rates indicating severe oversupply cycle. Peak expected in Q1 2026, with gradual decline throughout 2H 2026 as completions decelerate. Rate normalization to 6.0% or lower unlikely before 2027-2028.
indicator: Multifamily Rent Growth (Effective)
value: 0.0% to 0.8% annually
source: Yardi Matrix / National Apartment Association / Viking Capital (2025 actuals)
implication: Historically weak after post-pandemic boom. Consensus forecast: 2.0%-2.3% in 2026 as supply moderates. Ceiling of ~4%-5% in supply-constrained Northeast/Midwest markets; floor of -2% to +1% in oversupplied Sun Belt metros.
indicator: Multifamily New Supply (Completions)
value: ~297,000-508,000 units in 2025 (down from 700,000 in 2024 peak)
source: MSCI / National Apartment Association (January 2026)
implication: Construction-starts decline of 40%+ between 2023-2025; 2026 completions expected at 327,000-371,000 units, well below new household formation. Supply inflection represents critical turning point for rent recovery post-2H 2026.
indicator: Affordability Gap: Buy vs. Rent
value: New mortgage payment 35%-50% higher than average apartment rent
source: CBRE / Viking Capital / Marcus & Millichap (Q3 2024 - Late 2025)
implication: Structural driver: households with median income face $1,200+/month premium to buy vs. rent. This gap persists even with mortgage rate improvements and is primary driver of sustained rental demand and renter tenure extension.
indicator: Multifamily Absorption
value: 460,000-519,000 units in 2025
source: RealPage / Yardi Matrix (Full-year 2025)
implication: Exceptionally strong demand (record Q1 2025 performance) offsetting supply surge; expected to moderate to 350,000-400,000 units in 2026 due to weaker job growth and reduced immigration. Demand resilience despite oversupply signals underlying renter strength.
indicator: Regional Rent Growth Divergence
value: Northeast 4%-5%, Midwest 3%-4.5%, Sun Belt 1%-2%, West Coast 2%-3%
source: National Apartment Association / CoStar / Yardi Matrix (2026 Outlook)
implication: Supply-constrained markets with limited new construction outperform significantly. Coastal gateway cities (NYC, SF, Boston, DC) posting rent growth 3%-7% YoY; overbuilt metros (Austin -5.2%, Phoenix -4.1%) in structural weakness. Geographic selection critical for REIT performance.
indicator: Multifamily REIT FFO Growth Guidance
value: 1.5%-2.5% blended lease rate growth for 2026
source: UDR / Equity Residential / Essex Property (Q4 2025 Earnings, Feb 2026)
implication: Well below historical 3%+ averages; driven by low base-year comparisons and deferred pricing power. Operating expense pressures (insurance, labor) offset lease rate gains. Cap rates at 5.7% provide valuation support but limited upside until rent recovery accelerates.
indicator: Institutional Investor Sentiment on Multifamily
value: Lowest in 3 decades entering 2025; cautious recovery expected 2H 2026
source: Piper Sandler / Nareit / JPMorgan Research (Feb 2026)
implication: Investor sentiment crashed in 2025 due to disappointing rent growth and supply overhang; viewed as significant contrarian indicator. Recovery conditional on evident rent reacceleration and supply absorption, likely 2H 2026 inflection.
indicator: Population & Demand Tailwinds
value: 25-34 age cohort expanding; immigration policies restricting supply; delayed homebuying cohorts
source: Viking Capital / ULI-PwC / Fannie Mae (2026 Outlook)
implication: Positive: demographic expansion continues; generational delay in homebuying extends renter tenure. Negative: immigration restrictions reducing foreign-born household formation (+1 million/yr potential headwind); moderating job growth reducing income-driven demand.
indicator: Middle-Income Housing Shortage
value: ~500,000-600,000 unit deficit in homes priced at $260,000 or below
source: National Association of Realtors / CBRE (2026 Analysis)
implication: New multifamily construction heavily skewed toward luxury/Class A; workforce housing (Class B, build-to-rent) severely undersupplied. Renter-by-necessity (RBN) properties and affordable multifamily remain strong investment case versus oversupplied luxury.
indicator: Multifamily Investment Volume
value: $165.5 billion in 2025 (up 9.4% YoY)
source: MSCI Real Capital Analytics / Arbor Realty Trust (Feb 2026)
implication: Transaction activity rebounding despite soft fundamentals; suggests institutional capital positioning ahead of expected 2026-2027 recovery. Cap rates stable at 5.7% across property types—multifamily commands tightest yield floor.
indicator: REIT Valuation Premium Compression
value: REIT-to-equity valuation gap widest since GFC/COVID; REIT-to-private real estate gap longest since early 2000s
source: Nareit (2026 Outlook)
implication: Significant valuation asymmetry suggests both upside (if gaps close) and downside (if multifamily fundamentals remain weak). Current sentiment offers contrarian opportunity but timing risk is elevated given near-term rent headwinds.

Sources

February 16, 2026

Credit Research

(1 entry)
Bearish0-5 Year
Confidence: 7/10|Conviction: 6/10
Rental demand is expected to remain strong across income levels, driven by household formation, demographic shifts and limited for-sale options. However, the credit outlook for multifamily REITs is complex and moderately headwinds-driven over the 5-year horizon. The core thesis—that housing affordability drives sustained rental demand—is fundamentally sound, but REIT credit quality faces meaningful pressures from supply overhang, rising leverage, and refinancing risk. After peaking in 2024 and declining last year, annual new supply in 2026 should provide some relief relative to the unprecedented wave of recent years. However, the combination of a sizable lease-up backlog and an active construction pipeline means supply pressures will not dissipate quickly, particularly pronounced in the Sunbelt. The fundamental contradiction is stark: average effective apartment rents and median wages each increased by 32% from Q2 2019 to Q2 2025. Affordability deteriorated early in the pandemic but three years of stable rents allowed robust wage growth to catch up. This rent stabilization is positive for renters but constrains REIT revenue growth and debt serviceability. A historic wave of multifamily construction that began during the low-rate era is now delivering a massive number of new rental units. This supply surge is pushing national multifamily vacancy rates toward 5-6% and causing rent growth to decelerate sharply. The credit stress manifests through: (1) compressed NOI growth limiting debt service coverage, (2) widened borrowing spreads reflecting lender caution, and (3) elevated refinancing risk for debt maturing when rates remain elevated. Yardi has lowered its near-term national forecast to 0.5% growth in advertised asking rents for 2026, 1.0% in 2027, and 2.3% in 2028 before returning to the long-run average of 3-4%. Over a 5-year horizon, credit conditions depend critically on whether supply moderates fast enough to absorb existing units and rebuild rent growth momentum before 2028-2029.

Key Data Points

indicator: Multifamily New Supply Completions 2026
value: ~415,000 units projected (declining from ~600,000 peak in 2024)
source: ALN Apartment Data, January 2026
implication: Meaningful moderation from peak but supply remains elevated by historical standards; Sunbelt concentration continues to create regional market performance dispersion with credit implications for geographically-concentrated REIT portfolios.
indicator: Rent Growth Forecast 2026
value: 0.5% (advertised rents per Yardi Matrix); 2-3% (Redfin/market consensus)
source: Yardi Matrix, Redfin, National Apartment Association
implication: Essentially flat-to-modest rent growth significantly constrains REIT NOI expansion and debt service coverage ratio improvement; creates refinancing pressure if spreads widen.
indicator: Multifamily Construction Pipeline
value: ~951,000 units under construction (down 17.3% from March 2024 peak of 1.27M)
source: Zillow/CoStar data via Building Design+Construction, Q4 2025
implication: Pipeline contraction is moderating but lease-up backlog from prior years keeps pressure on occupancy and pricing power; credit fundamentals improve gradually as absorption progresses.
indicator: Multifamily Sector Cap Rates & REIT Valuations
value: 5.3% (CBRE estimate); multifamily cap rates ~130-150 bps above spread-implied rates
source: CBRE Cap Rate Analysis, February 2026
implication: Cap rate expansion reflects lender caution and compressed REIT valuations; higher spreads necessary to compensate for supply-demand mismatch risk and refinancing uncertainty.
indicator: Mortgage Spreads (Multifamily CMBS/Agency)
value: 150-160 bps over swaps (multifamily), up from 130-140 bps in prior cycles
source: Trepp, HFO Investment Real Estate (2025)
implication: Wider spreads reflect lender risk aversion; REITs refinancing debt face higher borrowing costs; implies higher leverage metrics and tighter covenant cushions.
indicator: Public Equity REIT Leverage Ratios (Average)
value: 33.8% debt-to-market-assets (Q1 2024); residential sector slightly higher
source: Nareit T-Tracker, Federal Reserve data
implication: REITs maintain conservative leverage vs. historical GFC levels, but leverage is rising as property valuations decline and debt maturities force refinancing at higher rates; unsecured debt at 79% of total provides some flexibility but not immune to spread widening.
indicator: Public REIT Debt Structure
value: 91% fixed-rate; 79% unsecured (as of 2023-2024 data)
source: Nareit
implication: Strong fixed-rate positioning limits refinancing rate shock risk; unsecured market access provides capital flexibility but requires maintaining investment-grade ratings and compliance with leverage covenants (typically 60% max unsecured leverage).
indicator: Net Interest Expense to NOI
value: <20% industry average (implying >5x interest coverage)
source: Goodwin LLP, REIT credit analysis
implication: Aggregate sector interest coverage remains adequate but is under pressure from (1) lower NOI growth and (2) refinancing at higher spreads; individual REIT credit quality diverging by market concentration and leverage.
indicator: Renter Cost Burden
value: ~50% of U.S. renters pay >30% of income on housing (record high)
source: Harvard Joint Center for Housing Studies, 2025
implication: Affordability crisis persists but is NOT translating to strong rent growth; demand is more about necessity than pricing power; REIT pricing power constrained by renter affordability ceiling.
indicator: National Multifamily Vacancy Rates
value: 4.5-5.5% (approaching normalized ranges after supply-driven compression)
source: CoStar, Yardi Matrix
implication: Vacancy trending toward healthy equilibrium but regional variance is high; tight markets (Northeast, Midwest, non-Sunbelt) may see rent growth, while Sunbelt oversupply persists; credit quality diverges by submarket.

Sources

February 16, 2026

Equity Research

(1 entry)
Neutral0-5 Year
Confidence: 7/10|Conviction: 6/10
Demand for apartments will rise as supply falls in 2026, leading to rising rents in many metro areas. The housing affordability crisis represents a powerful structural tailwind for rental housing, but equity investors must navigate a complex landscape of supply/demand dynamics, regional divergence, and near-term headwinds. Over the 5-year horizon, the thesis appears fundamentally sound but faces critical near-term execution risks that will materially affect REIT valuations and performance. A historic wave of multifamily construction that began during the low-rate era is now delivering a massive number of new rental units, pushing national multifamily vacancy rates toward 5-6% and causing rent growth to decelerate sharply. The supply wave peaked in 2024-2025, and completions are down roughly 50% from the 2024 peak of 700,000 units and are now at 350,000 to 508,000 in 2025, while in 2026 this should drop further to 327,000 to 371,000 due to elevated interest rates, tighter lending conditions, and construction costs weighing on new starts. This supply relief, combined with sustained underlying rental demand driven by homeownership unaffordability, creates a favorable medium-term outlook for rent growth and REIT profitability—but 2026 will mark a transition year of modest NOI pressure before conditions improve materially. Rental demand will remain strong through 2029 primarily because of underlying economic pressures; the fact that inflation and the cost of living are outpacing wage growth means that many people will find it difficult to afford homeownership, making renting the more viable option. Build-to-rent communities represent an emerging sub-segment opportunity, though concentrated among larger operators. Regional bifurcation will persist: coastal markets (Northeast, West Coast) and supply-constrained Midwest metros show stronger rent growth, while supply-saturated Sun Belt markets face extended rent stagnation before recovery accelerates in 2027-2028.

Key Data Points

indicator: National Multifamily Vacancy Rate (Jan 2026)
value: 7.3-8.1%
source: Apartment List, Apartments.com
implication: At record highs since 2017, reflecting supply overhang. Expected to peak mid-2026 before modest tightening. Materially headwind for near-term rent growth and landlord pricing power.
indicator: Multifamily Construction Supply Deliveries
value: 2024: 600K+ units; 2025: ~500K units; 2026 forecast: 327K-371K units
source: Apartment List, Nareit, NAA
implication: Sharp 40-50% decline in new supply from 2025 to 2026. Supply-demand inflection point likely mid-2026 to late 2027, supporting 2-3% rent growth recovery thereafter.
indicator: National Rent Growth 2026 Forecast
value: 2.3% (RealPage); 2.0% (NAA); 0.2% Q1 2026 (Apartments.com revised)
source: RealPage, National Apartment Association, Apartments.com
implication: Modest recovery from -0.7% to 0% in 2025. Represents normalization rather than acceleration. Sun Belt 1-2%, Northeast 4-5%, Midwest 3-4.5%.
indicator: Multifamily REIT 2026 NOI Guidance
value: MAA: -0.75%; AVB: +0.3%; EQR: modest slowdown
source: Mid-America Apartment Communities, AvalonBay, Equity Residential Q4 2025 earnings
implication: Operating expenses rising 2-3%+ while rent growth stalls at 0-0.3%. NOI compression = compressed multiples/valuations despite improving 2027+ outlook. Requires patience from equity investors.
indicator: Mortgage Rates & Home Prices
value: 30-yr FRM: 6.09% (Feb 2026); 1-2% home price growth forecast 2026
source: Freddie Mac, Redfin, JP Morgan, Zillow
implication: Affordability improving modestly but homeownership still unattainable for many. Sustains rental demand through 2027+. However, slower rate cuts than expected could weaken renter demand.
indicator: Multifamily REIT Sentiment & Valuations
value: Investor sentiment 'sourest in 3 decades' (Piper Sandler, Feb 2026); -7.8% REIT returns YTD 2025 vs +7.2% all-REIT average
source: Multifamily Dive, Nareit
implication: Extreme pessimism = valuation opportunity, but justified near-term. Market pricing in NOI headwinds through late 2026. Potential for positive sentiment reversal if 2H26 rent acceleration meets expectations.
indicator: Build-to-Rent (BTR) Pipeline & Growth
value: 64K+ units under construction; 139K in planning; 6.3% of 2025 deliveries, rising to 6.8% in 2026
source: Matthews, Yardi Matrix, Walker & Dunlop
implication: BTR occupancy 96%+, strong demand fundamentals. But supply will double in some markets (NC +152%, NE +255%). Premium to multifamily expected to compress 2027+ as supply grows.
indicator: Single-Family Rental (SFR) Rent Growth vs Multifamily
value: SFR: 4.4% YoY (Dec 2024); Multifamily: 2.4% YoY
source: Zillow
implication: SFR outperforming due to lower supply growth and suburban preference. Single-family REIT positioning potentially more attractive than traditional multifamily 2026-2027.
indicator: Regional Rent Growth Leaders 2026
value: San Francisco +6.3% YoY; Miami +3.8% forecast; Austin -4.8% YoY
source: Apartments.com, RealPage, CoStar
implication: Extreme regional divergence: supply-constrained coastal metros (SF, NY, Boston) see 3-5%+ growth; oversupplied Sun Belt (Austin, Denver, Phoenix) negative. Portfolio/geographic positioning critical.
indicator: Multifamily Cap Rates (2025)
value: 5.7% (unchanged from 2024); valuation down -1.3% for year
source: MSCI Real Capital Analytics, Arbor
implication: Cap rates stabilized but valuations softening. Spread between private and public REIT valuations widening, potentially favoring REITs for 2H26+ outperformance as fundamentals improve.
indicator: Housing Affordability Crisis Persistence
value: 30-yr mortgage payment now $2,337/month (down $92 YoY); 20 major metros forecast 'affordable' by EOY 2026 (Zillow)
source: Zillow, NAR, Freddie Mac
implication: Affordability improving but still 35% below pre-COVID levels. Structural rental demand persists through 2027+, supporting thesis. However, faster mortgage rate declines could accelerate homebuying and weaken rents.

Sources

February 16, 2026
Back to Research Feed